Steakhouse Details

Brooklyn and The Butcher in New Albany, Indiana transforms a historic 1870s hotel into a sophisticated modern steakhouse experience. This refined establishment showcases premium hand-cut steaks in an atmosphere that masterfully blends contemporary dining with historic charm. The restaurant’s commitment to quality is evident in their carefully curated selection of prime cuts, each prepared to exacting standards.

What Guests Say About the Menu and Selections

Visitors frequently commend the restaurant’s attention to temperature and preparation of steaks, with many noting the exceptional quality of the beef. The diverse menu selections receive particular praise, with people who visit this steakhouse often highlighting the seafood options as being on par with the premium steaks. Guests consistently mention the house-made sauces and creative side dishes as standout elements of their dining experience.

Location and Recognition

Situated in the heart of historic downtown New Albany, Indiana, just across the river from Louisville, Brooklyn and The Butcher has become a destination dining spot for the entire region. The restaurant’s location in a beautifully preserved 19th-century hotel adds to its appeal, making it a landmark in New Albany’s growing culinary scene. Its presence on SteakMap reflects its reputation as one of southern Indiana’s premier steakhouses, combining historical significance with contemporary culinary excellence. The restaurant’s proximity to Louisville makes it a popular choice for diners seeking an exceptional steakhouse experience in the greater metropolitan area.