The Hartley Restaurant stands as Madison, New Jersey’s premier destination for exceptional steakhouse dining, offering an elevated experience that combines classic steakhouse tradition with contemporary sophistication.

What Guests Say About the Menu and Selections

What People Say About the Atmosphere
Visitors consistently praise the restaurant’s refined yet welcoming ambiance, noting the perfect balance of intimate lighting and sophisticated décor. People who visit this steakhouse often mention the attentive service team, who demonstrate extensive knowledge of both the menu and wine selections. The dining room’s elegant wood paneling and leather seating create what many describe as the perfect setting for both special occasions and business dinners.

Location and Recognition

Beyond the Steaks — Noteworthy Highlights
While steaks take center stage, the restaurant offers an impressive array of seafood options, including a renowned raw bar featuring fresh East Coast oysters and lobster. The sommelier-curated wine list boasts over 200 selections, perfectly complementing the menu’s robust offerings. House-made desserts, particularly their signature crème brûlée, have become local favorites.
What Guests Say About the Menu and Selections
People who visit this steakhouse frequently commend the consistency and quality of their steaks, with many highlighting the exceptional temperature control and seasoning. Visitors particularly appreciate the diverse menu options, from classic cuts like New York Strip and Ribeye to specialized preparations that cater to various preferences. The side dishes, especially the truffle mac and cheese and roasted mushrooms, receive consistent praise for elevating the steakhouse experience.
Location and Recognition
Situated in the heart of Madison’s historic district, The Hartley Restaurant occupies a beautifully restored 19th-century building, adding character to its dining experience. The restaurant has earned recognition for its contribution to Madison’s culinary scene, maintaining its position as a go-to destination for steak enthusiasts in northern New Jersey. Its convenient location, just minutes from downtown Madison and the train station, makes it accessible to both locals and visitors from neighboring communities.
The steakhouse’s commitment to excellence, combined with its prime location and stellar reputation, has earned it a distinguished place in SteakMap’s curated selection of premium steakhouse destinations.