Steakhouse Details

Tellers: An American Chophouse, nestled in historic Islip, New York, transforms a beautifully preserved 1927 bank building into one of Long Island’s most distinctive dining destinations. This upscale steakhouse honors the building’s architectural heritage while serving exceptional USDA Prime steaks in an atmosphere that blends contemporary elegance with historic charm. The restaurant’s main dining room, housed in the former banking hall, features soaring 30-foot ceilings, original architectural details, and the historic vault that now serves as an intimate private dining space.

What Guests Say About the Menu and Selections

Visitors consistently praise the quality and preparation of the steaks, with many noting the excellent temperature control and seasoning. People who visit this steakhouse frequently mention the generous portions and the exceptional quality of the sides, particularly the truffle mac and cheese and crispy hash browns. The raw bar selections receive special mention, with many guests highlighting the freshness of the seafood offerings.

Location and Recognition

Located in the heart of Islip, New York, Tellers: An American Chophouse stands as a landmark destination for steak enthusiasts throughout Long Island. The restaurant’s unique setting in a historic bank building, combined with its reputation for exceptional steaks and service, has earned it recognition as one of Long Island’s premier steakhouses. Its convenient location, just minutes from Islip MacArthur Airport, makes it a popular choice for both locals and visitors seeking a memorable dining experience. The restaurant’s commitment to preserving local history while delivering contemporary culinary excellence has made it a cornerstone of the Long Island dining scene.